North Cumberland Historical Society
Conns Mills
Conns Mills, a small community situated at the head of the tides of Pugwash River was known as the “Head of the Tides” when John Fillmore, one of the River Philip Fillmores, settled there.
It was good timberland at that time, and he bought land on each side of the river and built a dam and saw mill there. It was reported that he prospered well. As more settlers came and started to clear land and farm, there was need of a grist mill to grind their grain into flour. As there was none handy, he built one, which was a great convenience to the pioneers. For several years, it was the only one between Wallace River and River Phillip. Then a big freshet came and destroyed the dam and mills, and as Mr. Fillmore was becoming aged, he decided to sell his property to some one who was in a better position to rebuild the dam and mills.
A few years later, the Conn family purchased the Fillmore properties, mill sites, etc. and rebuilt the dam and saw and grist mills. They operated the mills for several years. When the parents died, some of the family went elsewhere with the exception of Andrew. Andrew was more interested in farming than milling and the mills and pond privileges were sold to a company composed of MacPhersons. They built saw mills and did well in the lumbering business. The lumber was rafted down the river to Pugwash where it was loaded on to ships. Gradually one after another sold his share until only Angus MacPherson was left. His heirs roped it for some time and operated in the spring when there were logs to saw.
The grist mill was operated by Hugh MacPherson, who after having gotten his father’s homestead, took up farming and sold the mill to Jesse Demings.
In a few years, it was sold to another company, but it seems everyone was busy at some other business and the work of operating the grist mill was neglected. This was a great inconvenience to the farmers who had to now travel elsewhere to have their grain ground.
Because the Conn Family had contributed so much to the area, the place became known as Conn Mills. The father, William Conn, who came from Scotland, died in 1863 at the age of 74. He and his wife and two sons Andrew and Robert and daughter Margaret are buried in the Conns Mills Cemetery.
It is uncertain when the first settlers came or if John Fillmore was the first. The first burials recorded in the Conn Mills Cemetery are of two of his grandchildren in the years 1847 and 1849.
Other settlers whose names were on the tombstone were MacDougall, Cameron, Thompson, Ross, Finley, DeMings, MacLellans, Wakeham and Ives.
Conns Mills was once a flourishing community consisting of a store, school, post office, blacksmith shop and railway station. Of these, only the school is left and is now The Little Red School community hall.
The railroad from Pictou to Oxford Junction was completed in 1888 and added to the business of the community. From this station, many box cars loaded with lumber, pulpwood and pit wood were shipped over the years from the surrounding area.
Prior to the railroad, the river was used as the main source of transportation. In addition to lumber, which was sent down the river, supplies were brought up and carried or hauled to the surrounding communities. It has been told that some persons were know to have carried a barrel of flour on their backs. This was about two hundred pounds, and it was carried for a distance of three or four miles, much of it up hill. The bank east of the Ryan home is where the supplies were unloaded and the lumber sent on its ways. The supplies and pulpwood, etc. were moved on rafts.
Because of the significance of mills in the history of Conns Mills, stones which still remained from the grist mill were salvaged by Layton Ryan. Layton, who lived most of his life there, had a mill stone reconstructed on the corner of his lawn as a tribute to the early settlers who had the mills there an to those for whom the settlement was named.
The Ryans live on the same spot as Andrew Conn. The original home was owned by a grandson of Andrew, Conn Forrester, when it fell down in 1936.
This information is excerpted from an article for the Amherst News and Sentinel on Jan. 6, 1915 by Mr. A. S. Ross of Thompson Station.
In 1871, land was granted by Richard Chestnut for the Pugwash River Church, now the United Church.
The first schoolhouse, Pugwash River East, was moved to Mabrey Newsons, where it was used as a pig house.
In 1907, the telephone line was built. In 1915 the Mutual (Pugwash River) Company took over and still is owner at this time.
In 1941, a home and all adjoining buildings of Mr. and Mrs. W. P. MacNutt, Conns Mills were completely destroyed by fire. Mr. and Mrs. MacNutt and family had moved to Oxford the previous spring and the house was occupied by Mr. and Mrs. John Mahoney and family. There was no insurance. The wind carried the fire across the road to the home and blacksmith shop of Mr. and Mrs. Hibbert Saddall, but they were saved.
Mar. 1947 - The house of Howard Ferdinand, Conns Mills was badly damaged by fire. The fire was discovered burning in the attic shortly after 9 a.m. As the phone was out of order, the children spread the word and neighbors and people from Conns Mills Station came quickly. The Family removed all the furniture and after a hard battle, the fire was extinguished. A steel roof on the building helped check the fire.
Feb. 1948 - A fire of undetermined origin completely destroyed the home of Mr. and Mrs. Isaac Forrest and familiy. The fire had gained gread headway when discovered in the evening and within a few minutes the house had burned to the ground. The unfortunate family lost almost everything.
These notes are from a scrap book kept by Mrs. Dorothy Ryan
Civilian Marriage in Conns Mills or by citizens of Conns Mills 1889 - 1910
27-08-1889 Pugwash River Presbyterian Rev James A McKenzie
THOMPSON George H 25 B farmer Conns Mills Cum Co Conns Mills Cum Co Abraham & Eveline
CHESTNUT Annie 17 S Pugwash River Cum Co North River Cum Co Richard & Eliza
01-08-1893 Conns Mills Cum Co Methodist Rev Benjamin Hills
GIBSON John R (Lt) 38 W Salvation Army Lewiston Maine USA Liverpool England James & Mary
DEMINGS Mary J 26 S Conns Mills Cum Co Conns Mills Cum Co Jesse D & Susan
17-10-1893 Conns Mills Cum Co Presbyterian Rev James A McKenzie
FORRESTER Lyndia J 40 W hotel keeper Pictou Pic Co Saint John NB John L & Lydia
CONN Maggie R 24 S Conn Mills Cum Co Conn Mills Cum Co Andrew & Jane
26-12-1893 Conns Mills Cum Co Baptist Rev C H Haverstock
LATTIE William 44 B farmer Pugwash Jct Pugwash Jct Joseph & Elizabeth
THOMPSON Jane 49 S Conn Mills Conn Mills Abraham & Eveline
02-06-1894 Conns Mills Cum Co Methodist Rev Benjamin Hills
JONES Lewis 50 B farmer Dohertys Brook Cum Co Wallace Bay Cum Co Benjamin & Ann
DEWAR Elizabeth 47 W Conn Mills Cum Co River Philip Cum Co Stephen & Mary
18-11-1896 Oxford Cum Co Baptist Rev P D Nowlan
PATTERSON James 55 W farmer Conns Mills Cum Co Eire Joseph & Mary
TEED Armenia 48 W Wentworth Cum Co River Philip Cum Co Weatherbee & Mary
28-12-1898 Wallace Stn Cum Co Methodist Rev John W Shepherdson
FILLMORE Arthur H 24 B farmer Conns Mills Cum Co Conns Mills Cum Co Charles & Elizabeth
ROBERTSON Ethel 24 S Wallace Stn Cum Co Wallace Stn Cum Co John & Sarah
22-10-1902 Conns Mills Cum Co Presbyterian Rev A D McIntosh
DEMMINGS Harry 22 B fireman Pugwash Cum Co Pugwash Cum Co Alexander & Adeline
MCPHERSON Victoria 20 S Conn Mills Cum Co Conn Mills Cum Co Angus & Christie
02-09-1903 Middleboro Cum Co Methodist Rev Donald Farquhar
FINLEY Frederick B 21 B farmer Conns Mills Cum Co Leicester Cum Co Elisha & Mary
SCARLET Lilian M 24 S Middleboro Cum Co Cole Creek Ind USA Fred A & Lydia
14-12-1904 Conns Mills Cum Co Methodist Rev Donald Farquhar
MCNUTT Warren P 39 B blacksmith Conn Mills Cum Co Port Philip Cum Co Hazen & Dinah
DE MINGO Eva S 33 S Conn Mills Cum Co Pugwash River Cum Co Jesse & Susan
23-12-1908 Conns Mills Cum Co Methodist Rev Adam B Higgins
ANGEVINE Charles Ross 21 B farmer Six Mile Road Truro Col Co Peter & Ellen
ROSS Annie Amelia 20 S Conn Mills Cum Co Victoria Cum Co Albert & Martha
29-09-1909 Conns Mills Cum Co Methodist Rev William J Croft
LETCHER William Thomas 25 B miner Springhill Cum Co Chignecto William & Eliza
MATTINSON Carrie Jean 25 S Conns Mills Cum Co Oxford Cum Co John W & Cynthia
21-12-1910 Amherst Cum Co Methodist Rev Hamilton Wigle
MCLEOD Alexander Howard 35 B farmer Pugwash Jct Cum Co Pugwash Jct Cum Co Stewart & Margaret
MATTINSON Isey Isabella 28 S Conns Mills Cum Co Oxford Cum Co Wesley & Cynthia